AI Search Favors National Chains Over Independent Pool Builders: Study

The study found that AI assistants often overlooked established independent builders, even when they ranked among the top results on Google Maps.

2 MIN READ

Image courtesy: TeroVesalainen/bigstockphoto.com

Artificial intelligence (AI) tools such as Google’s AI Overview are changing how consumers find businesses online. A recent study suggests that independent pool builders must rethink their online marketing strategies or risk losing visibility.

Seen and Found, a design-led marketing agency for small businesses, found that AI assistants often overlooked established independent builders, even when they ranked among the top results on Google Maps. Instead, the tools favored national chains.

In November 2026, the agency tested 200 independent pool builders across 10 US cities: Phoenix, Scottsdale, Dallas, Houston, Austin, San Antonio, Tampa, Orlando, Las Vegas and Sacramento.

The firm identified the top 20 independent builders in each city on Google Maps. It then asked ChatGPT, Gemini, and Google AI Overview questions that homeowners might ask, such as, “Who is the best pool builder in Phoenix?”

The results showed that 72% of the independent builders did not appear in responses from any of the AI assistants.

National chains featured among the most common recommendations. Seen and Found suggests that their stronger Google review profiles and presence on directories and websites such as poolpad.com and Houzz may explain their visibility.

The study also found that AI assistants mentioned builders more frequently when third-party websites featured them in “best of” lists.

“When homeowners ask AI to recommend a pool builder, most of the established independent builders we tested weren’t in the answers. ChatGPT cited pool directories … or the trade press in most of its answers, and the builder’s own website in very few,” says Ognen Petrovski, founder and CEO of Seen and Found.

The full study, with charts, the method, and the anonymized data, is available here.

About the Author

PSN Staff